Should the Trail Blazers keep competing around Damian Lillard and CJ McCollum, or would they be better off starting over? In this September 2018 Monday Mailbag, we took on the question of tanking—and whether Portland’s roster had a future worth building around.
Looking back: Portland’s answer to the tanking question
Historical update (November 2026): It’s easy to forget why this was even a debate. The Blazers had just finished the 2017–18 regular season with 49 wins and the third seed in the West, only to get swept by the New Orleans Pelicans in the first round. That was a rough ending, and it raised a fair question: Was this team’s ceiling too low to justify sticking with the same core? Or was the smarter move to keep trying to win with Lillard, McCollum and Jusuf Nurkić?
Well, the Blazers certainly didn’t tank in 2018–19. They won 53 games, finished third in the West again, and ended up making their deepest playoff run in nearly two decades. They eliminated Oklahoma City in five games—remember Damian Lillard’s unforgettable series-ending three over Paul George?—then beat Denver in a seven-game series to reach the Western Conference Finals for the first time since 2000.
And they did all of that despite losing Nurkić to a devastating leg injury late in the regular season. The run finally ended with a four-game sweep by Golden State, but getting that far was a pretty convincing argument that the roster still had something worth playing for.
Of course, making the conference finals wasn’t the same as building a championship team, and the franchise eventually faced bigger decisions about its future. But looking back at that September 2018 debate, it’s hard to imagine telling the Blazers to deliberately lose when a 53-win season and a trip to the Western Conference Finals were just around the corner. Sometimes there really is something to be said for giving your team another shot.
For more of the preseason mood, revisit They’re Sleeping on the Blazers ONCE AGAIN!, another 2018 video about how little respect Portland was getting.
